Evelyn K. Pentikis, Esq.
Trained NJ Divorce Attorney-Mediator

Divorce Mediation:
You Design Your Future

You've both landed in the same quiet place: you stopped growing together, and it's better if you're apart. What comes next doesn't have to get nasty, and it doesn't have to cost you everything you've built.

Flat fee packages, so you know the cost before we begin. Most mediations finish in months, not the years a contested divorce takes.

Morning fog over the Navesink River at Oceanic Bridge, Monmouth County, New Jersey
View from Oceanic Bridge,
Navesink River, Monmouth County
Services

Mediation Basics in New Jersey

What is Divorce Mediation?

Mediation is a conversation with a guide. I'm the neutral in the room, which means I'm not on anyone's side and I'm not deciding anything for you. My job is to keep you both talking, ask the questions that get at what actually matters, and help you land somewhere you can both live with.

The process is structured enough to keep us moving, flexible enough to sit with an idea until it works. Nobody hands down a ruling. You two decide. We work through the real details: the marital home, the pet, the wine cellar. I help you organize your finances and schedules so you can have productive conversations about splitting money, assets, and time with your kids. At the end, I draft a Memorandum of Understanding capturing every nuanced agreement, from parenting plans to equitable distribution.

You take that completed MOU to an attorney to draft the Marital Settlement Agreement and file in New Jersey. No Discovery costs, no drawn-out lawyer correspondence, no months of legal bills.

You avoid the courtroom, the expensive attorneys, and the long waiting times, and your paperwork gets cut down dramatically. Best of all, the two of you stay in charge of the outcome instead of handing that decision to someone who has never met your family.

New Jersey mediation is governed by the Uniform Mediation Act, and every state has its own version.

Is Mediation mandatory?

Mediation is voluntary. Nobody can force you into an agreement, and you can stop at any point.

There is one wrinkle worth knowing about. If you're already inside a court proceeding, the court will send you to mediation as part of that process. That's a different animal from what happens here. Court mediation runs on someone else's calendar, with someone else's rules, and it's one stop on a track you didn't lay down.

Private mediation is yours. You choose the mediator, you set the pace, and you decide what ends up in the agreement. Nobody is deciding for you and you're free to make any decision that works for you regardless what the law says.

Do I still need a lawyer?

You don't need a lawyer to mediate. The fear is that without one you'll get taken advantage of, and that fear isn't silly. But the real risk is an insincere mediator, and that's not how I work.

If I see an imbalance, I stop and send you both to your own attorneys before we go any further. Two moments where a lawyer earns their keep: when something comes up that you can't get past, and at the end, when your Memorandum of Understanding gets reviewed by independent counsel and turned into the Marital Settlement Agreement.

That document is the map for your new life. Have someone read it.

Plans

Pick the Plan That Works for You

Most couples can complete a mediation under 10 hours over a few weeks or months.

Simple Split Plan
$3,200 flat. For couples with no kids or pets and streamlined asset division. Includes up to 8 hours of mediator time: sessions, preparation, and your Memorandum of Understanding. No separate drafting fee. Additional time at $350/hour.
Smart Split Plan
$5,200 flat. Comprehensive planning for families with kids and pets, including a detailed, personalized parenting plan. Includes up to 14 hours of mediator time: sessions, preparation, and your Memorandum of Understanding. No separate drafting fee. Additional time at $350/hour.
Pay as you go Plan
Not sure you want to commit to a full package? That's okay, you can pay as you go. Rates start at $350/per hour and payment will be required before each session.

Mediation typically costs a fraction of a traditional divorce. Third party surveys put the average New Jersey divorce at roughly $12,500 to $15,000, but neither the New Jersey Judiciary nor the State Bar publishes fee data, so treat that as an average, not a quote. Your case is its own.

We're happy to offer a 10% discount to teachers and police officers and healthcare workers* in recognition of their service to our community.

*anyone primarily engaged in actions whose intent is to enhance health and wellness.

Who We Serve

No Two Families Untangle the Same Way

What mediation looks like depends on who is at the table, whether there are children, whether you were ever married, and what each of you is trying to protect.

Parents

Parenting plans built around real Tuesday nights, not court templates. Schedules, holidays, decision-making, and how you will handle the things you cannot predict yet.

Couples without children

Property, support, and a clean close. Often the fastest and least expensive route through a divorce, and the one where mediation saves the most.

Same-sex and LGBTQ+ couples

Relationships that began long before marriage equality, non-biological parent standing, second-parent adoption, the questions a standard form never anticipates.

Unmarried and cohabiting partners

A shared home, shared money, and often shared children, with no marriage to dissolve. You still need agreements that hold up.

Later-in-life divorce

Retirement accounts, pensions, health coverage, and adult children with opinions. Decades of joined finances to unwind carefully rather than quickly.

Pet families

New Jersey treats pets as property. Mediation is where you can build a real sharing arrangement instead of asking a judge to pick a winner.

However you come to the table

Self-represented

No attorney? Mediation is the whole process, not a step inside someone else’s.

Represented by counsel

Your attorney stays in the loop. Nothing is signed before they review the Memorandum of Understanding.

Collaborative divorce

Collaboratively trained (forthcoming) and able to work as part of a collaborative team.

Court-referred

Rule 1:40 qualified for Superior Court referrals in family (forthcoming) and civil matters.

About

Experienced Divorce Mediator Helping You Organize and Overcome a Difficult Time

150+
Mediation Hours
NJ
Licensed Attorney
NJ
Specialized  Parenting Coordinator
2025
Municipal Mediator of the Year, NJ Superior Court, Monmouth Vicinage

Answers to the most asked questions

What are you actually getting for your money with P8 Mediations?
arro icon

More than a cheaper divorce. Yes, the price is a fraction of what litigation costs, but that was never really the point. The real value is in how you come through this, and who you are on the other side. Here's what you're getting:

Mediator judgment. You're working with a mediator who's also an attorney, someone who knows how equitable distribution actually works in New Jersey and can read the room at the same time. I lead with my intuition. And if I ever see an imbalance, or someone being taken advantage of, I stop and tell you both to go consult your own attorneys before we move forward. That judgment is what keeps the whole thing fair.

Support through the process. I don't hand you a verdict and send you on your way. I walk two people, calmly and one step at a time, through untangling what marriage tied together. When it starts to feel like a lot, and it will, we slow down. It's okay to not get it; it's a lot. You're gonna be okay, and I'll help you.

Access to a curated network of professionals. When you need a financial specialist, a therapist, a real estate expert, or an attorney for a particular step, you're not starting from a blank search bar. You get access to a curated network of professionals I know and trust, the right person for the moment, already vetted.

Care and attention. You get lived empathy, not performed empathy. I genuinely care whether the deal is fair, and I'm generous with my time.

Speed. Because we're collaborating instead of fighting, this moves. Most mediated divorces finish in three to five months instead of the year-plus a contested case can drag on, which means less money spent, and far less of your life spent living in limbo.

You walk in frightened and confused and walk out steadier and in charge, with a memorandum of understanding you shaped yourself, a clear map of what your life is actually going to look like, with the kids and with the assets and liabilities you've split. That's the value.

Is there a best time of year to get divorced?
arro icon

The best time is when you're both ready, when two people have quietly accepted they've stopped growing together and it's better to be apart. That readiness matters more than any date on the calendar. That said, there are a few practical timing pieces worth knowing, because a little planning can save you money and stress.

Your taxes turn on one date. Your marital status on December 31 sets your tax filing status for that whole year. If everything is final by then, you're treated as single for the entire year; if you wait, you can file jointly one last time, which is sometimes simpler and less expensive. There's no universally right answer, it depends on your numbers, so this is a great question for a tax professional, and I'm happy to point you to one.

A couple of money details hinge on timing too. If you'll sell the family home, a married couple can exclude up to $500,000 of gain from capital gains tax; after the divorce is final, that usually drops to $250,000 per person. And bonuses often land in January or March, if one of you is expecting one, the timing can affect whether it's part of what you split. None of this has to be scary. It's just money, just energy, and we work through it together.

There's also a real "January effect": family lawyers see inquiries jump 25 to 30 percent every January, with filings actually peaking around March. People get through the holidays, hit the new year, and feel ready for a fresh start. If that's you, you're in good company, but there's no prize for rushing. We'll move at a pace that lets you understand each step.

So, no single best month. The right time is when you're ready, with a few tax and money details worth timing thoughtfully. Take a deep breath, we'll figure out the timing together.

What if mediation doesn't work?
arro icon

There are no guarantees that every issue will be resolved in mediation, and it's fair to ask what happens if it doesn't. The good news is that you lose very little by trying. Mediation is non-binding, so nothing is final until you both sign a settlement agreement which means you keep every legal right you started with, including the option to go to court.

If you can't reach a full agreement, the progress you made isn't wasted. Any issues you did settle can be put in writing and carried forward, which narrows what's left to resolve and usually saves time and money if the case proceeds. From there you have options: you might return to mediation later once emotions have settled, move to a collaborative divorce, use arbitration for a binding decision on the remaining issues, or proceed to traditional litigation. Even a partial agreement leaves you further ahead than starting from scratch in court.

In our experience, most couples who come to mediation in good faith reach a full agreement. But we'll always be honest with you about how things are progressing, and if mediation isn't serving you, we'll help you understand your next step rather than keep you in a process that isn't working.

We were together for years before we could legally marry. Will our whole history count, or just the date on the marriage certificate?
arro icon

This is one of the most important questions a same-sex couple can ask, and I'm glad you're asking it. Here's the honest picture: New Jersey often looks at the date you legally married or entered a civil union as the starting line, not the day your life together actually began. For couples who built a home, a life, and savings together for years or decades before marriage was even legal, that can matter a great deal. Property held in one person's name from before the marriage can be treated as that person's alone, and the length of the marriage can affect alimony. The law here is still evolving, and there isn't a single answer a court will always land on.

That's exactly where mediation gives you something a courtroom can't: you two decide. Instead of leaving it to a judge who may only see the certificate date, you get to untangle your real history together, to honor the ten or twenty years you actually shared, not just the five the paperwork recognizes, and shape an agreement that feels fair to both of you. That's self-determination, and it's the whole point.

There are a couple of related pieces we'll look at, depending on your situation. If you're dissolving a civil union, you have the same rights as a married couple: alimony, equitable distribution, all of it; a domestic partnership is different and carries fewer of those rights, so we'll get clear on which one you actually have. And if you have children, where one of you is the biological or adoptive parent and the other has been a parent in every way that matters, we'll make sure the parenting plan reflects the family you truly are. Where parentage was never formally established, that's worth getting your own legal advice on, and I'll tell you plainly if I think you need it.

Is mediation right for every couple?
arro icon

Mediation works best when both spouses are willing to communicate and negotiate in good faith, even if you don't currently agree on much. It's a strong fit for the majority of divorces. Cases involving abuse, a serious power imbalance, or a spouse who refuses to participate honestly may need a different approach and we'll tell you candidly if we think that's the case.

Is there any free or low-cost mediation available?
arro icon

Yes. New Jersey's court-connected mediation program provides the first two hours of economic mediation at no charge under Court Rule 1:40-4(b), after which mediators charge their standard rates. Private mediation, like the service we offer at P8, gives you more flexibility over scheduling, pace, and the mediator you work with.

What are the court filing fees in New Jersey?
arro icon

Court filing fees are set by the state and apply no matter how you resolve your divorce. The spouse who files pays $300 ($325 if there are children), and the responding spouse pays $175. These are separate from any attorney or mediator fees.

Court filing fees and the free-mediation provision are set by the New Jersey Courts. This information is for general education and is not legal advice.

Why is mediation so much less expensive?
arro icon

Litigation costs pile up because each spouse hires a separate attorney, and those attorneys bill by the hour, typically $450 to $750 (and higher) per hour in New Jersey, for every letter, motion, discovery request, and court appearance. Mediation replaces that adversarial back-and-forth with a shared, neutral process. One professional guides both of you toward an agreement, so you're paying for resolution rather than for a fight.

How does mediation compare to going to court?
arro icon

Mediation generally costs 70 to 90 percent less than contested litigation, where each spouse can pay $15,000 to $50,000 or more before the case resolves. It's also far faster: most mediated divorces finish in three to five months, compared with the 12- to 18-month average for a contested case in court.

Beyond the numbers, mediation keeps decisions in your hands rather than a judge's, and it tends to preserve the working relationship you'll need if you're co-parenting for years to come.

The cost and timeline comparisons above reflect New Jersey market ranges reported by family law and mediation practitioners; your own case may differ. This information is for general education and is not legal advice.

How much does divorce mediation cost?
arro icon

A complete mediated divorce in New Jersey typically costs between $3,000 and $8,000 total, most of it shared between the two spouses rather than duplicated by two separate attorneys. Most couples reach a full agreement in three to ten sessions over the course of three to five months. Attorneys drafting MSAs actually look for how long the mediation practice took and are suspicious if it's too quick. Unraveling the legal relationship takes time and requires due diligence.

This is a typical range, not a quote. What your mediation actually costs depends on the complexity of your situation and the number of sessions you need. This information is for general education and is not legal advice.

How much does a divorce cost in New Jersey?
arro icon

It depends almost entirely on how you resolve it. A litigated divorce in New Jersey runs about $12,500 to $15,000 on average once you add up attorney fees, court costs, and related expenses. But that figure hides an enormous range. An uncontested divorce where both spouses agree on the major issues can total as little as $3,000 to $10,000. A contested divorce that involves discovery, negotiation, and court appearances commonly costs $15,000 to $35,000 per spouse, and a high-conflict case that goes to trial can exceed $50,000 to $100,000 per spouse.

The single biggest driver of cost isn't the paperwork: it's conflict, and how long the process drags on.

The cost figures above reflect New Jersey market ranges reported by family law and mediation practitioners; actual costs vary by circumstance. This information is for general education and is not legal advice.

Blog

Latest Insights

Browse Articles
Money and Divorce Mediation: How to Face Your Finances

Money and Divorce Mediation: How to Face Your Finances

A divorce mediator on the emotional side of money. A plain language playbook for financial mediation, from budgets and dividing assets to spousal support, child support, and retirement.
What Happens to the House? Untangling Home Equity in a New Jersey Divorce

What Happens to the House? Untangling Home Equity in a New Jersey Divorce

People walk in terrified of the numbers and walk out running their own budget, understanding their own equity, in charge of their own money for the first time in years. There's real power in that.
How Does Equitable Distribution Work in NJ Divorce

How Does Equitable Distribution Work in NJ Divorce

Equitable does not mean equal in New Jersey. A plain language guide to what counts as marital property, how the sixteen statutory factors actually work, and the seven mistakes that cost divorcing couples the most money.
Start With One
Conversation

Thirty minutes, no charge, no commitment. I'll learn a little about where things stand and walk you through how I work. Bring your questions, even the ones you think are dumb.